《How to Review a Paper 》.pdf

How to Review a Paper How to Review a Paper Prof. Dr. Guowang Xu Elsevier Author Workshop Apr. 17, 2009 Opening Question Opening Question • Why is peer review a part of the scholarly publishing process? 2 Objectives Objectives • What is the history of peer review and what role does it serve? • Why should I consider being a reviewer? • How do I carry out a proper and thorough review? 3 What is the history of peer review and What is the history of peer review and what role does it serve? what role does it serve? Background on Peer Review Background on Peer Review • Cornerstone of the whole scholarly publication system • Maintains integrity in the advancement of science • Well-established process over 300 years old 5 n o i t c u s d o r r e w P e w i e v i e v R e R r e r n e o i P o t a